G
Garbuz
Banned
Russian
- Oct 11, 2011
- #1
She likes to have a glass of milk before sleep/going to bed.
Frankly speaking, I don't like either of them. But can't think of a better phrase. Would you help?
Thanks in advance.
R
Rover_KE
Senior Member
Northwest England - near Blackburn, Lancashire
British English
- Oct 11, 2011
- #2
There's nothing with 'She likes to have a glass of milk before going to bed'.
Rover
ewie
Senior Member
Manchester
English English
- Oct 11, 2011
- #3
Help with what? There's nothing at all wrong with before going to bed. (before sleep doesn't work at all for me.)
J
james.zeng
Member
Shanghai
Chinese
- Oct 11, 2011
- #4
but if she is on bed and trying to sleep, what we can say? Before sleep or before going to bed?
T
temple09
Senior Member
English - British
- Oct 11, 2011
- #5
james.zeng said:
but if she is on bed and trying to sleep, what we can say? Before sleep or before going to bed?
I don't really understand what you mean. "Going to bed" means that they are going to get into their bed and try to sleep. So you say "She likes to have a glass of milk before going to bed". She's not exactly going to "like" being in bed, being unable to sleep and then (whilst lying down with her eyes shut) drink milk, is she? Besides, the "before sleep" option would not be said in this way.
G
George French
Senior Member
English - UK
- Oct 11, 2011
- #6
She likes to have a glass of milk before sleeping.
She likes to have a glass of milk before going to bed.
Their meanings are slightly different.
I can easily fall asleep in front of my PC... Especially when I am Wordreferencing and I have just had a glass of warm milk...
GF..
There is also "She likes to have a glass of milk before having a sleep." ... There are a few more..
D
djmc
Senior Member
France
English - United Kingdom
- Oct 11, 2011
- #7
There are two scenarios. "She likes to have a glass of milk before going to bed" - she pours a glass of milk, drinks it and then goes to bed. "She likes to have a glass of milk before going to sleep" - She has some milk beside the bed, reads or watches the television in bed, when she is tired she drinks the milk and goes to sleep. Many people do not sleep immediately they go to bed.
Copyright
Member Emeritus
Penang
American English
- Oct 11, 2011
- #8
You will also hear, at least in American English:
She likes to have a glass of milk before bed.
She likes to have a glass of mile before bedtime.
But "She likes to have a glass of milk before going to bed" is just fine.
AngelEyes
Senior Member
Detroit, Michigan
English - United States
- Oct 11, 2011
- #9
You could also say, "She has a glass of milk at bedtime to help her sleep."
The "helps him/her/me/you sleep" is a very common way of saying this in AE.
wolfbm1
Senior Member
Poland
Polish
- Mar 7, 2012
- #10
Copyright said:
You will also hear, at least in American English:
She likes to have a glass of milk before bed.
She likes to have a glass of mile before bedtime.But "She likes to have a glass of milk before going to bed" is just fine.
Is there anything wrong with saying: "I like having a snack of fruit before bed."
Copyright
Member Emeritus
Penang
American English
- Mar 7, 2012
- #11
wolfbm1 said:
Is there anything wrong with saying: "I like having a snack of fruit before bed."
Other than the fact that "snack of fruit" makes me spit my milk, no.*
*(Sorry, I've just never heard it before and the sound of it seems quite hilarious at the moment, although there's probably nothing wrong with it ... just with me.)
cycloneviv
Senior Member
Perth, Western Australia
English - Australia
- Mar 7, 2012
- #12
Just to be weird... I actually like (indeed need, but for reasons I won't go into) to have a glass of milk while in bed, before going to sleep. I then brush my teeth, in bed, and read until I start to nod off (don't ask!) Nevertheless, I don't think I'd say I "like to have a glass of milk before sleep". That sounds a bit odd. I'd probably have to go into detail and describe the situation as I have in my first sentence.
wolfbm1
Senior Member
Poland
Polish
- Mar 7, 2012
- #13
Copyright said:
Other than the fact that "snack of fruit" makes me spit my milk, no.*
*(Sorry, I've just never heard it before and the sound of it seems quite hilarious at the moment, although there's probably nothing wrong with it ... just with me.)
Thank you, Copyright. I like having a snack = I enjoy it. I like to have a snack = I do it habitually.
S
sunnyweather
Senior Member
Polish
- Sep 16, 2019
- #14
And how about:
I always read a book before going to bed. (Would this sentence imply I read a book before I go to bed?)
I always read a book before going to sleep. (Would it imply I like to read in bed?)
Would it be possible to say: I always read a book before sleep.
R
Rover_KE
Senior Member
Northwest England - near Blackburn, Lancashire
British English
- Sep 16, 2019
- #15
1. Yes.
2. Yes.
3. It's possible to say it. A native English-speaker wouldn't.
ewie
Senior Member
Manchester
English English
- Sep 17, 2019
- #16
sunnyweather said:
I always read a book before going to bed. (Would this sentence imply I read a book before I go to bed?)
I always read a book before going to sleep. (Would it imply I like to read in bed?)
They both imply that you read a whole book.
Try:
I always read before going to bed.
I always have a read before going to bed.*
I always have a read before I go to bed.*
---------------------
I always read in bed before I go to sleep.
I always have a read in bed before going to sleep.*
*I
thinkthis is BrE only ... not sure.
S
sunnyweather
Senior Member
Polish
- Sep 17, 2019
- #17
Thank you for your comments. 'Does I read a book before going to bed.' really mean I read the whole book? What about 'I read (some) books before going to bed.' Would it imply I read several books from cover to cover?
lingobingo
Senior Member
London
English - England
- Sep 17, 2019
- #18
No one would say that. It implies that you read several books on the same evening. I’m not familiar with “have a read” either. It’s very informal. Ewie’s unstarred suggestions are by far the most common:
I always read before going to bed.
I always read in bed before I go to sleep.
Or: I always read for a while before going down to sleep.
F
Franco-filly
Senior Member
Southern England
English - Southern England
- Sep 17, 2019
- #19
wolfbm1 said:
Is there anything wrong with saying: "I like having a snack of fruit before bed."
You could say "I like to snack on fruit before I go to bed."
S
sunnyweather
Senior Member
Polish
- Sep 19, 2019
- #20
Thank you.
ewie
Senior Member
Manchester
English English
- Sep 20, 2019
- #21
lingobingo said:
Or: I always read for a while before going down to sleep.
Heyho, I'm not familiar with that one, LB
lingobingo
Senior Member
London
English - England
- Sep 20, 2019
- #22
You may be right. It’s hard to find any examples of it that aren’t about babies!
R
Rover_KE
Senior Member
Northwest England - near Blackburn, Lancashire
British English
- Sep 20, 2019
- #23
lingobingo said:
I always read for a while before going down to sleep.
I'd say '... before settling down to sleep'.
You must log in or register to reply here.